Private Big Toe Fusion (First MTP Arthrodesis) | Find Accredited Surgeons

What is big toe fusion surgery?

First MTP arthrodesis (often called a big toe fusion) is a surgery for the foot that relieves severe pain caused by arthritis or extreme bunions. It works by removing the damaged cartilage and permanently joining the two bones of the big toe joint (the metatarsophalangeal joint) together into one solid bone.

Think of the big toe joint like a door hinge that must bend every time you push off to take a step. When severe arthritis (a condition called hallux rigidus) wears away the smooth cartilage, the bones grind directly against each other. This creates massive bone spurs, severe stiffness, and sharp pain every time you walk.

What actually happens

Cartilage removal (clean the joint): The surgeon shaves away the remaining damaged cartilage and painful bone spurs to expose healthy, bleeding bone on both sides of the joint.
Fusion (lock it in place): Instead of trying to preserve the damaged hinge, the surgeon positions the toe at a precise, slightly upward angle (so you can still walk smoothly). They then tightly lock the bones together using a combination of a small titanium plate and screws. Over the next few months, your body heals the two bones together into one solid piece.

Why do it? When clinical exams and X-rays confirm severe, bone-on-bone arthritis and every step hurts, a fusion permanently stops the grinding. While the toe will no longer bend at that specific knuckle, the pain relief is usually excellent. Most people walk much better after surgery than they did before because the sharp arthritis pain is completely gone.

Why do Canadians get big toe fusion surgery done privately?

Shorter wait times

Public waitlists for orthopaedic foot and ankle consults, X-rays, and OR time can be long—especially because toe arthritis is often not considered a medical emergency. Private centres can sometimes line up assessment and surgery in weeks rather than months, cutting time spent limping, avoiding walks, and squeezing into painful shoes.

Choice and control

Going private can let you:

Pick your surgeon (an orthopaedic foot and ankle specialist) based on foot surgery experience and case volume.
Schedule around work, holidays, caregiving, or travel.
Get a clear plan for why a fusion vs. a joint replacement is recommended for your specific lifestyle and foot shape.

Peace of mind

You know who’s operating, when it’s happening, and what hardware they’ll use. Predictable dates make it easier to arrange time off work and prepare for the required resting and recovery period.

Preventing further decline

Function: Ongoing big toe pain alters the way you walk (causing a severe limp or walking on the outside of your foot). This can cause worsening secondary pain in your knees, hips, and lower back.
Performance and wellbeing: Faster relief can protect your sleep, mood, and ability to comfortably exercise, hike, or work on your feet.

Integrated care

Private pathways may offer streamlined imaging, advanced surgical hardware, and coordinated anaesthesia/pain/physiotherapy plans—with virtual follow‑ups if you live far away.

Why use Surgency

For Canadians who want surgery in weeks, not months

Surgency is a free resource by a Canadian physician in the public system to help you find the right surgeon for your needs.

Click to Browse Surgeons

Big toe fusion: what to expect

Typical first MTP arthrodesis surgery takes about 1 to 1.5 hours of operating time. Add time at the centre for check‑in, anaesthesia, and recovery (usually a few extra hours).

Basic steps

1. Check‑in and confirmation

You meet the team, confirm the correct foot, review imaging, and go over the plan. Safety checks are done (including marking the correct toe).

2. Anaesthesia

Usually general anaesthesia (you’re fully asleep) or twilight sedation. The anaesthesiologist or surgeon will often perform a regional "nerve block" (freezing the foot/ankle) to ensure you wake up with very little pain.

3. Position and prep

You’re positioned comfortably on your back. The foot and leg are cleaned and draped sterilely. A tourniquet is often used on the calf to minimize bleeding.

4. Small incision and exposure

An incision (usually 2 to 3 inches long) is made on the top or side of the big toe joint. The surgeon gently moves tissues aside to reach the bones.

5. Joint preparation

The surgeon removes the massive bone spurs and completely strips away the remaining damaged cartilage to prepare the bone ends for fusion.

6. Implant placement (Fixation)

The toe is placed in the perfect position for walking. The surgeon then secures the two bones together using small titanium screws, and often places a small metal plate across the top of the joint for extra stability.

7. Rinse and check

The surgeon uses a live X-ray machine (fluoroscopy) to confirm the hardware is perfectly placed and the toe angle is exact.

8. Close up

Layers are closed with sutures (stitches). The foot is heavily bandaged and placed in a specialized rigid post-op shoe or a surgical boot.

9. Wake‑up and instructions

You recover in the post‑anaesthesia care unit, begin gentle movement when safe, and receive wound‑care instructions. Almost all patients go home the same day.

What to expect from the recovery process

Every foot is different—follow your surgeon’s plan. A fusion requires the bones to physically knit together, which takes time.

Week 1

Reality check:
Foot throbbing, swelling, and a feeling of heaviness are extremely common. The nerve block will wear off in the first 24 to 48 hours, causing a temporary spike in pain.
Goals: Control pain, keep swelling down, and protect the hardware.
Activities: Elevation is your full-time job. Keep your foot elevated above your heart as much as possible. You will wear a stiff surgical shoe or boot. Depending on your surgeon, you may be allowed to walk strictly on your heel (heel-bearing only) or you may need to use crutches/a knee scooter to keep all weight off the foot. Keep the bandages completely dry.

Weeks 2–4

Still annoying but improving.
Goals: Wound healing, transition to more mobility, avoid flare‑ups.
Activities: You will have your first follow-up to check the incision and remove stitches. You will likely continue wearing the stiff post-op shoe to protect the toe. You can gradually spend more time on your feet, but swelling will still occur if you stand too long.

Weeks 5–8

The work phase.
Goals: Confirm bone healing and transition to normal footwear.
Activities: You will get new X-rays around the 6-week mark to check if the bones have fused. Once cleared by your surgeon, you can usually transition out of the surgical shoe into a stiff-soled, roomy running shoe (like a Hoka). You will slowly return to light household tasks and longer walks.

Weeks 9–12

Confidence building.
Goals: Near‑normal daily activity; walking without a limp.
Activities: Progress your walking distances. The bone is usually solidly fused by this point. You can return to most low-impact activities like cycling or swimming.

Months 3–6

Back to most normal life.
Goals: Return to usual routines, hiking, and heavier activities.
Activities: You can add impact and heavier activity with clearance. Note: Foot swelling after a long day can persist for up to 6 months to a year. This is normal.

Helpful tips

Elevate constantly early on: If your foot is pointing down in the first week, it will swell and throb intensely.
Shoe choice matters: Because your big toe no longer bends, shoes with a "rocker bottom" (a curved sole) will make walking feel incredibly smooth and natural. High heels are usually no longer an option after this surgery.
Knee scooter: If you are told to be non-weight-bearing, a knee scooter is much easier than crutches.
Bowel plan: Pain meds can constipate—hydrate and use fibre/stool softeners if needed.

Red flags—call your care team

Fever, spreading redness, or foul drainage from the incision.
Calf pain, swelling, or tenderness behind the knee (signs of a potential blood clot).
Severe, worsening pain that medication cannot touch.
Your lesser toes become completely numb, freezing cold, or blue.

How to choose a surgeon and clinic

Choosing your surgeon is a major benefit of pursuing private surgery. Here’s how to choose wisely for a first MTP arthrodesis (big toe fusion).

What to look for

Experience and volume (foot and ankle specific)

Ask how many big toe fusions they perform each year.
A big toe fusion is highly “precision-dependent” because:

the toe must be fused at the exact right angle (too flat or too high ruins your ability to walk or wear shoes).
the bone ends must be prepared perfectly to ensure they knit together (fuse) completely.
outcomes depend on using the right mix of plates and screws for your specific bone quality.

Also ask about their case mix:

Arthritis fusions vs. severe bunion fusions (different underlying mechanics).
Revision cases (fixing a previous toe surgery that failed, which is much more complex).

Credentials and training

Verify licensure with your provincial college (CPSO Ontario, CPSBC BC, CPSA Alberta, CMQ Québec, etc.).
Look for FRCSC-certified orthopaedic surgeons with fellowship training in foot and ankle surgery.
Bonus: Surgeons who regularly treat complex foot deformities or participate in orthopaedic foot and ankle societies.

For a more in-depth guide read, How to Understand Surgeon Credentials in Canada

Outcomes and safety (ask for real numbers)

Request recent data, ideally for foot fusions specifically:

Non-union rate: (How often do the bones fail to heal together, requiring a second surgery?)
Infection rate: (Foot incisions are further from the heart and can be slower to heal).
Hardware removal rate: (How often do the plates/screws irritate the skin so much they need to be taken out later?)
Patient-reported outcomes: Pain relief, ability to return to walking/hiking, and satisfaction with shoe fit.

Clear indications and alternatives

Make sure they confirm you’re a good candidate for a fusion, not just a cleanup procedure.
A careful surgeon should explicitly assess:

whether your arthritis is truly "bone-on-bone" (end-stage) rather than mild/moderate.
whether a simpler surgery, like a cheilectomy (just shaving off the bone spurs without fusing the joint), would be enough for you.
why a fusion is better for your lifestyle than a big toe joint replacement (artificial toe joints exist but often wear out or fail in active people, making fusion the gold standard).

Surgical plan and implant strategy

Ask:

What hardware do you use (e.g., a top plate with screws, or just crossed screws) and why?
How do you determine the perfect angle to position the toe during surgery?
What is your plan if my bone quality is softer than expected?

Imaging and planning (must be thorough)

Good programs use imaging to confirm candidacy:

Weight-bearing X-rays: To see the foot structure exactly as it is when you stand on it.
Sometimes a CT scan or MRI to look at bone cysts, overall bone health, or other damaged joints in the foot.

Facility accreditation and safety systems

Choose accredited centres (e.g., Accreditation Canada / CAAASF) with:

modern fluoroscopy (live X-ray) in the operating room to ensure perfect hardware placement.
experienced anaesthesia teams skilled in regional foot/ankle nerve blocks.
a clear transfer pathway to a hospital if needed.

Rehab integration (bone healing requires strict protocols)

You want a written plan for:

weight-bearing status (heel-walking only vs. completely off the foot on a scooter).
surgical boot or stiff shoe timeline.
when it is safe to return to driving (especially if it is your right foot).

Transparent pricing (hardware can be a major line item)

Request an itemized quote including:

surgeon fee
facility/OR fees
anaesthesia
implant/hardware cost (titanium plates and screws).
imaging/fluoroscopy
follow-ups (and whether virtual follow-ups are included).

Clarify add-ons:

fixing other hammer toes at the same time.
cost of the specialized post-op surgical shoe or boot.

Questions to ask at your big toe fusion consultation

Surgeon and plan

How many first MTP fusions do you perform yearly?
Why are you recommending a fusion instead of just shaving the bone spurs (cheilectomy) or an artificial joint?
What exact angle do you fuse the toe at, and will I be able to wear a slight heel or running shoes?

Technique and safety

What are your rates of non-union (bones not healing) and infection?
Will I likely need a second surgery to remove the metal hardware later?

Recovery and after-care

Can I put weight on my heel right after surgery, or do I need a knee scooter?
When can I drive, return to work, and resume long walks?
What symptoms should prompt an urgent call (calf pain, severe swelling, numb toes)?

Costs and logistics

What exactly is included in my quote (especially the plates and screws)?
How are follow-ups and X-rays handled if I live out of province?

Signals of a high-quality foot fusion program

Performs big toe fusions regularly and clearly explains why it's the gold standard for severe arthritis.
Shares complication rates (like non-union) openly and sets realistic expectations about the long recovery.
Operates in an accredited facility with experienced anaesthesia and emergency pathways.
Provides a strict, written recovery and weight-bearing plan.
Offers transparent, itemized pricing—including the hardware costs.

Big toe fusion - frequently asked questions

How do I know this surgery is right for me?

First MTP arthrodesis (big toe fusion) is a specific solution for end-stage arthritis (hallux rigidus) or massive joint deformity. It is right for patients who need to eliminate severe, daily pain and are willing to trade the bending motion of the joint for a pain-free, stable foot.

Signs a big toe fusion might be right for you

Severe, daily pain: Every step hurts, especially when pushing off your toes.
Loss of motion is already happening: Your toe is already so stiff from arthritis and massive bone spurs that it barely bends anyway.
Shoe limitations: You cannot fit into normal shoes due to pain or the sheer size of the bone spurs/bunion.
Failed conservative care: Stiff-soled shoes, custom orthotics, and cortisone injections no longer provide relief.
Diagnostic clarity: X-rays show "bone-on-bone" grinding with no healthy cartilage left.

When it might not be the right option (or other treatments are better)

Mild to moderate arthritis: If you still have good cartilage left, a smaller surgery (cheilectomy) to just shave off the bone spurs might relieve your pain while keeping the joint moving.
You require high heels for work/life: Once the big toe is fused, you generally cannot wear a shoe with a heel higher than 1.5 to 2 inches.
You are a high-level sprinter or dancer: While you can run and hike with a fusion, activities requiring an extreme push-off or pointing the toes (like ballet) will be permanently altered.

When to get assessed sooner

Skin breakdown: If massive bone spurs are rubbing against your shoes and causing open sores or ulcers, you need an assessment to prevent severe infection.
Severe altered gait: If the toe pain is causing you to walk on the outside of your foot, leading to sharp pain in your ankle, knee, or hip.

Do I need a referral?

No, you do not need a referral for private foot surgery in Canada. You can book a consultation directly with a surgeon, and they will review your options and diagnostics.

How do I prepare for surgery?

Your surgeon’s instructions come first—follow their plan if it differs.

Prehab and health optimization

Prepare your upper body and "good" leg

Depending on your surgeon's protocol, you may be on crutches or a knee scooter for weeks. Work on upper body and core strength now.
Practise balancing on your unaffected leg.

Quit nicotine

Crucial for bone fusion: The two bones must grow into each other to be successful. Nicotine severely chokes off the blood supply needed for bones to heal. Smoking dramatically increases the risk of a "non-union" (the fusion failing) and wound infections. Stop 4 to 6 weeks before surgery.

Medication review

Share all prescriptions, OTC meds, and supplements.
Pause blood thinners and anti‑inflammatories as directed (NSAIDs can sometimes interfere with bone healing).

Home prep

Safe layout

Clear clutter and remove loose rugs to prevent tripping.
Set up a “recovery zone” on the main floor with essentials (water, meds, phone charger) easily reachable without standing up.

Mobility aids and elevation

Rent or buy a knee scooter if you are instructed to be non-weight-bearing.
Gather firm pillows. You will need to elevate your foot above your heart constantly for the first 1–2 weeks to control throbbing and swelling.

Bath setup

Non‑slip mat and a shower chair (balancing on one foot in a wet shower is dangerous).
Get a waterproof cast cover or large garbage bags/tape to keep your surgical bandages completely dry.

Clothing

Baggy pants or shorts: Your foot will be in a bulky bandage and a rigid post-op shoe/boot. Skinny jeans or tight sweatpants will not fit over it.

Food, meds, and surgery‑day prep

Meal prep

Pre-cook and freeze meals, or have easy-to-grab foods ready so you don't have to stand at the stove on one leg.

Constipation plan

Pain meds slow the gut; have stool softeners and hydration ready.

Skin prep

Use the antiseptic wash as directed.
Do not shave your foot or toes yourself to avoid micro-cuts, which can force the surgeon to cancel the operation due to infection risk.

What to bring

Health card/ID, medication list, and imaging.
Your post-op shoe or walking boot (if provided to you beforehand).
Loose clothing for the ride home.

Red flags to know

Calf pain: Severe pain, swelling, or heat in the calf behind your knee (potential blood clot).
Wound issues: Spreading redness, foul drainage, or a sudden spike in pain under the bandages.
Numb, freezing toes: If your lesser toes become cold, blue, or completely numb, the bandages may be too tight, cutting off circulation.
Chest pain or shortness of breath: Requires immediate emergency care.

What are the risks involved with surgery?

Your personal risk depends on your bone quality, anatomy, and general health. Discuss your specific risks with your surgeon.

Common and usually temporary

Foot swelling: Swelling is entirely normal and can persist for 6 to 12 months after foot surgery, especially at the end of the day.
Throbbing pain when standing: In the early weeks, every time you lower your foot to the ground, blood rushes in and causes intense throbbing. Elevation is key.
Transfer pain: As you adjust to walking with a fused toe, you may temporarily feel aches in other parts of your foot or ankle.

Less common

Non-union (bones fail to fuse): The most specific risk for this surgery. If the bones do not knit together into one solid piece, you may continue to have pain and the hardware may break. This often requires a second surgery. (Risk is much higher in smokers).
Hardware irritation: The thin skin on the top of the foot means you might feel the plate or screws rubbing against your shoes. They can be removed in a minor surgery after the bone has fully fused (usually after a year).
Infection: Risk is low but serious. Foot wounds can be slow to heal.

Procedure-specific considerations (Big Toe Fusion)

Malunion (fused at the wrong angle): If the toe is fused pointing too high, it rubs on the top of your shoe. If fused too flat, you will painfully roll over the tip of the toe when walking. Precision is why surgeon selection matters.
Adjacent joint arthritis: Because the big toe no longer bends, the joint behind it (or the ankle) has to absorb more stress. Over many years, this can lead to arthritis in those neighboring joints.

Uncommon but important

Nerve damage: Small sensory nerves run over the top of the toe. They can be stretched or injured, leading to permanent numbness on the side of the toe or chronic nerve pain.
Blood clots (DVT): Reduced mobility and leg splinting increase clot risk, though less so than major knee or hip surgery.
Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS): A rare nervous system overreaction causing severe, ongoing foot pain, swelling, and skin color changes.

How you can lower risk

Stop nicotine completely: This is the single best way to prevent a non-union and wound infection.
Obey the weight-bearing rules: Do not walk on the foot until your surgeon explicitly says the X-rays show it is safe.
Elevate constantly: Keeping the foot above the heart drastically reduces swelling, pain, and tension on the healing incision.

What are the risks of delaying or not pursuing surgery?

Your situation depends on how bad your daily pain is, whether you can still walk comfortably, and how fast the arthritis is progressing.

Main risks of delaying (when symptoms are significant)

Severe joint destruction

As the cartilage completely disappears, the bones grind together. This creates massive, sharp bone spurs that stretch the skin, make wearing any shoes excruciating, and can lead to skin ulcers.

Compensatory pain (Kinetic chain issues)

If your big toe hurts, your body subconsciously forces you to walk on the outside edge of your foot to avoid bending the toe. Over months and years, this abnormal limping causes painful stress fractures, ankle problems, knee tendonitis, and hip or lower back pain.

Loss of mobility and fitness

Avoiding walking, hiking, or exercising due to foot pain leads to cardiovascular decline, weight gain, and muscle atrophy, which impacts your overall health.

Medication dependence

Relying on daily NSAIDs (like Advil or Aleve) to get through the day carries long-term risks for your stomach lining, blood pressure, and kidneys.

When watchful waiting can be reasonable

Your pain is mild and only happens after extreme activity (like a long run).
You found a combination of stiff-soled shoes (like Hoka running shoes) and custom orthotics that manage your symptoms well.
You are willing to modify your lifestyle to avoid activities that bend the toe.

When not to delay (seek prompt assessment)

Skin breakdown: The bone spurs have grown so large they are rubbing the skin raw inside your shoes, risking a severe infection.
Severe altered gait: You are limping so badly that your knees and hips are now in constant pain.
Inability to walk: The pain prevents you from completing basic daily tasks like grocery shopping or walking your dog.

I still have questions

If you still have questions, please feel free to contact us directly.

Please note: Surgency is not a clinic itself. Nor can we help with emergency situations, or provide personalized medical advice—that is between you and your surgeon. If you are experiencing acute or severe symptoms, please present to your local emergency department or urgent care centre.

How Surgency works

Decide where to go

Search by specialty

Schedule a consult